By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. House Dayne | Game of Thrones Wiki | Fandom For more information, please see our Even if it's true, the armor that they used at that time couldn't have been near as good and durable as the one used currently. sometimes a huge advantage in offence, physical size and strength can be enough to beat speed and skill. What surprised you? He beat Arthur Dayne, Brandon Stark and Barristan at Harrenhal, before crowing Lyanna queen of love and beauty. Since Robert could never even hit Arthur at the edge of Arthur's threat range, then, yes, it would have been all too easy for Arthur to avoid Robert's attacks until Robert tired. There is even the possibility that because of his weapon's design and weight that it could get stuck in the stone. Although I do think /u/TheRealDills should've won based on his arguments. News and discussions relating to George R. R. Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire" novels, his Westeros-based short stories, the "Game of Thrones" and "House of the Dragon" TV series, and all things ASOIAF - but with particular emphasis on the written series. Ser Arthur Dayne vs Young Robert Baratheon - Comic Vine A fun parody of Game of Thrones where I meme the crap out of Robert Baratheon and add in a lot of creative and funny edits.Thank you to my Patrons: DXXG, Wes. Another thread made me think about this, and I'm curious what opinions you guys have. Can IRL science and blacksmiths forge a katana that would How many superpowers can Batman get in 24 hours? . Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Any suggestions going forward? I think it's universally accepted that he is at the top of the list. For those who wants to support me on Patreon; http://patreon.com/NedimCanIncebay ( I really don't want to make anyone feel obligated to give me anything, but. For a full schedule, please see the tournament hub. I agree, Robert was a beast. Prime versions for the GoT team . dayne with dawn should be a bit above robert, due to speed and skill. Put 'em in an arena, though, and the odds would turn the other way, I think. Robert beat Prince Rhaegar & Rhaegar was a legendary swordsman. It's a reasonable assumption that Robert is able to stave in and crush practically any armor with a clean hit. He didn't say anything about them being the top swordsmen to the best of my knowledge, but it does kinda go without saying anyway. Female Robert Baratheon * Robarra was dauntless, a force of nature, the centre of any room she was in even at sixteen. www.patreon.com/WilliamBernard===== Equipment Used For Video Edits:2021 Apple iMac 24. Arthur only needs one or two well placed stabs, and at the range in which he would stab, Robert can't even touch him with that warhammer. Jorelle Lannister wanted nothing more than to be just like her father, with one exception. If you enjoy my #shorts, please consider becoming a Patreon :) . Because a fighter of Dayne's caliber would realize the weaknesses of Robert's unique weapon and use it against him. If they fight like they did in the show, I give Robert decent odds at defending the weak joints of his armor and crushing chests in. The demon of the trident vs. the sword of the morning. Robert could possibly win unlike Ned. Robertbaratheon Stories - Wattpad Honestly swords in general better as secondary weapons on the field. I would still go for Arthur though, out of skill, and swiftness. A blade we know very little about other than Jaimie's description when he was knighted. They were once minor kings, styling themselves as Kings of the Torrentine . An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works What are those weaknesses? Our fifth debate and first semi-final, (Robert Baratheon vs. Arthur Dayne) was a matchup between two reknowned warriors with legendary weapons that added to their ability. Menu. That might be for the best, actually, it's good to keep these debates grounded in realistic battle strategy rather than subjective character opinions. Gerold vs. Robert (Fight 17) ~ Tower of the Hand He didn't even start his training . They probably said the same thing about Rhaegar. 41.2K 1.1K 12. Robert's hammer is deadly, but incredibly heavy and despite his freakish strength, Robert would have to commit when he is attacking with such a heavy weapon. Yeah, pretty much. There's four potential weapons coming at Dayne, and while he does some decent maneuvering to keep people attacking from the same angle, they still fail at hitting him while his back is turned or while he's doing that fancy, 'slit a guys throat with both swords while he's blocking' move. You are indeed where you belong. Not because Robert was as skilled as him, but because he's got several advantages during the battle of the Trident: (I'll assume it's a 1-on-1 fight without anyone actively trying to interrupt or join the fight, otherwise it's a "normal" battlefield). Jamie says Dawn is so sharp Danye cut his shoulder, completely bypassing the tunic and whatever else he was wearing, without Jaimie feeling it. Robert Baratheon vs. Jaime Lannister Thread starter Lee-Sensei; Start date Apr 26, 2019 Apr 26, 2019 The weight of Robert's weapon also affects him after he's finished an attack. All in all, I think a confrontation between Arthur Dayne and Robert Baratheon ends with Dayne floating down a crimson river 7 or 8 times out of 10. I expected this one to be fairly close, not having Robert win by a hefty margin. See the current bracket here. Westeros' greatest warrior in his prime. But a person can only take so much before enough is enough. (Spoilers Extended) Theory Request: Why did no Dragon Press J to jump to the feed. . Arthur Dayne vs. Robert Baratheon - General (ASoIaF) - Westeros Dayne. (No Spoilers) Robert Baratheon VS Arthur Dayne on the Trident - a Would his brute strength have overpowered the incredible swordsmanship of The Sword of the Morning. Even a glancing blow would at least hurt - maybe even somewhat cripple - his opponent, as well as giving him an opening for a follow-up attack. By Southpaw89, December 4, 2012 in General (ASoIaF . Robert Baratheon vs. Jaime Lannister | Page 2 | FanVerse As per The Battle of the Seven Stars we know that Valayrian Steel can slice through plate armor and Dawn is described as sharp as it, so I think I would favor Dayne in this round up. [Tournament] Winner of Debate #5 (Robert Baratheon vs. Arthur Dayne A Forum of Ice and Fire A Song of Ice and Fire & Game of Thrones I don't have a quote so don't take me for my word, but I believe GRRM stated that without Dawn, Dayne and Prime Selmy would be the top swordsmen. One on hand, we have King Bobby B. himself. This is always available (in addition to lots more info) on the tournament hub. Dayne in the show is not impressive. Fck the fat King Bobby B! I asked him if he would be willing to nominate himself again on behalf of Sir Arthur during the nomination process, so we could have a champion versus champion battle and he happily obliged. He sounds like he's quite literally the best fighter mentioned in the series. Prelude. The skill that he possesses is a dark horse since our only real source is 15 year old Jaime. Sir Arthur Dayne is a GOD! Dayne, on the other hand, would have to stab/slash very precisely in order to get through/past Robert's armor, not to mention scoring a fatal hit. Arthur Dayne had a much stronger argument. He is just on another level. What do you think, guys? Arthur Dayne How will the amazing knight do against his dominant opponent? Do they make How well would Jesus Christ do at the Olympic Games? 7 years ago #3 EquinoxMonster I'm. I've got to say I'm pretty surprised I won the debate, seeing as how Arthur's fandom on this sub Reddit is pretty immense but thanks to everyone who voted and I can't wait to see Robert through to becoming the tournament champ ;). He also keeps blocking attacks with both swords, which is a weaker block than blocking with just one sword with a two hand grip. As for Robert vs Dayne/Barristan don't get me wrong, Robert can't win either of those fights I think, but he certainly could hold in 1vs1 with either of them, enough for Clegane team helping him . Cookie Notice I was dying to chime in during the debate that Arthur Dayne would not be "running away" from Robert Baratheon, or tiring himself out by evading Robert's attacks, he would be performing simple distance control. The problem is that we don't know a lot about Dayne. I agree with the warhammer part. Ser Arthur Dayne vs Young Robert Baratheon #1 Edited By EquinoxMonster 7 years ago #2 cpt_nice Ser Dayne, if he can use Dawn. He's still lively, he's very much so into him prime, and he's experienced in combat. Distance control simply means stepping backwards to ensure that your enemy stays just at the edge of your threat range. Assuming book versions, Dayne 6/10 with high difficulty. Got to a give a shout out to /u/TheRealDills for giving a great debate! THE NIGHT | arthur dayne by Olivia. He was a massive guy! I got the info from an offhand source at Westros.org so don't quote me. Warhammers were designed to be brutal against armored opponents, and Robert had the option of wielding it with a shield. I'm ganna give it to Robert, one hit and Arthur is done. Whyd you vote the way you did? CONTEXT Robert Baratheon Let's first take a look at Robert. Robert Baratheon vs. Jaime Lannister | Page 4 | FanVerse Dayne, while we know very little about him, would not be able to overpower Robert, and would therefore likely be forced to avoid a direct head-on-confrontation. Debate #6 between Barristan Selmy and Syrio Forel will take place on Wednesday, time yet to be determined. Robert Baratheon (in his prime) vs Oberyn Martell, who would win? The Dayne knight that bears the sword is granted the title of "the . This is the most basic combat skill any castle-trained lordling would be taught and you can be certain that Dayne was a master of it. #1. #1 Edited By phillip33. The winner of the golden flair and the champion who convinced everyone that his warrior would win is: codylac for Robert Baratheon! Geralt of Rivia vs Game of Thrones team. Physicality As several other answers here have observed, Robert was a more physically imposing figure, taller, stronger, and perhaps even faster t. Also easy to get distracted. Robert was a big, hulking dude, and it's safe to assume he didn't base his fighting on agile movements. I thought TheRealDills should have been hammering home that any missed attack by Robert when he was pressing forward would have left him open to a counter attack, and also I really thought Dills had it on the question of Robert's rage. High difficulty. (Spoilers Main) Who is this Celtigar woman missing an eye? Robert's champion did, and I acknowledged that in my vote. As fight itself. game of thrones fanfiction starks win
Gaco Roof Coverage Rate, Jquery Validation Add Custom Rule, Fisher Information Geometric Distribution, Semolina Pasta Calories 100g, Premier League Kits 22/23 Ranked, 115 Mercury 4-stroke Oil Filter, Advanced Rx Pharmacy Pennsylvania, Lead Lag Correlation Matlab,